White House Causes Frustration In Private And Public Responses To Gun Violence

Mar 29, 2021
Originally published on March 29, 2021 11:44 am

As President Biden called on senators to quickly pass legislation to tighten the nation's background checks system, he said that he did not need to "wait another minute" to address the epidemic of gun violence.

Biden's comments the day after 10 people were killed in a mass shooting at a Boulder, Colo., grocery store were welcome news for gun violence prevention advocates after seeing no action so far on an issue the president campaigned on tackling seriously. Those same advocates were dumbfounded to hear Biden say later in the week that infrastructure, not reforming the nation's gun laws, would remain his administration's next priority.

Manny Oliver, whose son was killed in the 2018 school shooting in Parkland, Fla., recalled speaking to Biden after his son's death and discussing their shared experience of grief. He addressed Biden directly during a press conference on Friday.

"Now, Mr. Biden, you are the president of the United States. I am still the father of Joaquin, carrying my pain. And I will be the father of Joaquin regardless of who is the president of the United States" he said. "But as long as you are inside the White House, I need to go to you and ask you to go back to that conversation that we had and start doing something."

Before the shootings in Boulder and the Atlanta-area turned the nation's attention to gun control, the Biden administration was already holding meetings with key stakeholders focused on the issue — an attempt to deliberately plan action to prevent gun violence, rather than reacting to tragedy. But grassroots violence prevention advocates have raised questions about the way the administration initially convened those meetings.

Data underscore the urgency they feel. According to the Gun Violence Archive, gun violence killed nearly 20,000 people across the United States in 2020. Another 24,000 people died by suicide with a gun. And yet, the only major debate about gun policy in the last year came after two mass shootings grabbed major headlines.

The fleeting, reactive nature of these debates has been a particular frustration of some gun violence prevention advocates.

"For too long our policy has been reactive. Only serving as a measure to react whenever gun violence occurs, react whenever another shooting happens, whether it be on our streets and in our schools," said Luis Hernandez, a co-founder of Youth Over Guns. "But there hasn't been strong policy that actually prevents what's going on."

Susan Rice, who heads up the Domestic Policy Council, and Cedric Richmond, in charge of the Office of Public Engagement, have been leading the administration's outreach to gun control groups.

After an initial meeting in February that included groups like Everytown for Gun Safety, Moms Demand Action, Giffords and Brady, a number of leaders of groups who were not included wrote to the White House expressing their concerns.

"Some of these advocates were amazing organizations. I don't discredit them, I think they're doing some great work. But the challenge for us was that they were all white and they didn't bring a lived experience, and didn't represent the urban communities persay," said Eddie Bocanegra, who heads up an initiative run by the Heartland Alliance called READI Chicago.

Bocanegra had also been a part of a group that came together during the Biden transition to work on gun violence related policies.

"We felt very disrespected by that, it was kind of a blow," Bocanegra said. "Who and what's informing the president's decisions in the next 100 days."

While the administration did ultimately hold several meetings with grassroots violence prevention groups, they say the initial exclusion speaks to a familiar pattern of being overlooked during the debate over how to best address gun violence.

"If we only talk about gun violence when there's a mass shooting, then we're going to have a certain perspective of what gun violence looks like and what the remedies are," said Antonio Cediel of Faith in Action.

Kina Collins of the Illinois Council Against Handgun Violence, pointed to the proposed assault weapons ban as an example, something Biden championed as a senator and spoke forcefully in favor of renewing after the Boulder shooting.

"That's not what we're dealing with in communities that deal with everyday gun violence," she said. "We're dealing with hand guns. We're dealing with straw purchases, we're dealing with illegal guns floating across the borders into states. That's what we're dealing with."

Collins also pointed out the racial disparities in gun violence. In Cook County, Ill., there were 875 gun-related homicides in the year 2020. Most of those killings happened in the city of Chicago.

"Seventy-eight percent of those people were African Americans," Collins said. "I don't know any place in the country if we saw that many white folks dying of gun violence that we wouldn't call it a state of emergency."

During the campaign, Biden said gun violence was an epidemic. During a 2019 candidate town hall organized by Giffords and March For Our Lives, Alycia Moaton of Good Kids Mad City asked Biden about his plan to reduce gun violence in inner cities.

Biden pledged to dedicate $900 million to community-based violence prevention programs in 40 cities with the highest rates of gun violence. In his response, he tried to relate to Moaton in describing the racial disparities in who is killed.

"There is a mass shooting in my city of Wilmington, your city of Chicago, all of the cities that have large black and brown populations every single day," Biden said. "What gets the headlines, and it should, are the mass shootings."

These groups are now calling on the administration to go further, and dedicate more than $5 billion dollars to these efforts over the next eight years.

"Trillions of dollars were given to businesses to bail them out, and we're just saying put a fraction of that into our children's lives," said LIFE Camp founder Erica Ford. "How do you think people feel when nobody cares about their children? When every day Black children are being shot in the street and we're acting like it's not even happening?"

Community violence intervention programs are among the areas that the White House is considering addressing by way of executive action. The White House has released no details on how it might fund community violence prevention programs, or at what level, and declined to comment when asked by NPR.

White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki said at a press briefing on Friday that Biden understands the frustration of gun control advocates at the pace of action, but added that their frustration "should be vented at the members of the House and Senate who voted against the measures the president supports, and we'd certainly support their advocacy in that regard."

Psaski did not provide a timetable, but said that there would be "more efforts" by Biden and the administration to move on the issue, including executive actions.

Some advocates have said that the fact that two senior officials who are both Black are taking a leading role in engaging on gun policy adds a more nuanced understanding of the issues.

"The reality is that Susan Rice and Cedric Richmond are both Black people," Hernandez said. "They're folks that know too well what the Black experience is in America and so they bring that lens to the work."

But they say this also means that gun violence is wedged in between all of the other priorities within Rice's portfolio, and a number of gun control groups have called for the White House to appoint a director of gun violence prevention, a recommendation that the White House has not committed to.

"Until we do so, we're just going to have Susan Rice and the rest of the domestic policy team that's focusing on every other domestic policy trying to also address gun violence when we are in the middle of a public health crisis that requires someone's full attention," he said.

Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

NOEL KING, HOST:

More than 19,000 people in this country were killed last year by someone with a gun. That's according to the Gun Violence Archive. Another 24,000 people died by suicide with a gun. President Biden campaigned on trying to solve gun violence, but reacting to the recent mass shootings was not the way the White House planned to do this. Juana Summers covers race and justice for NPR Politics, and she's been looking into what's happening here. Good morning, Juana.

JUANA SUMMERS, BYLINE: Good morning.

KING: The White House was doing work on gun violence before these mass shootings in the Atlanta area and then in Boulder, Colo. What were they up to? What efforts were underway?

SUMMERS: Yeah, so I've been talking to a number of people focused on community violence prevention who have been in touch with the administration. And they tell me that the national conversation that springs up after high-profile mass shootings often leaves out the gun violence that happens in the communities that they live in. That violence is actually responsible for most gun homicides in this country. And these activists say this also means that the way that this country tries to respond to gun violence often falls short of what their communities need. Take, for example, one reform that President Biden called for when he spoke after that shooting in Boulder.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

PRESIDENT JOE BIDEN: We can ban assault weapons and high-capacity magazines in this country once again. I got that done when I was a senator. It passed. It was law for the longest time, and it brought down these mass killings. We should do it again.

SUMMERS: That's the kind of proposal that some advocates say wouldn't have a meaningful impact on urban gun violence.

KINA COLLINS: That's not what we're dealing with in communities that deal with everyday gun violence. What we're dealing with handguns. We're dealing with straw purchasers. We're dealing with illegal guns floating across the borders into states. That's what we're dealing with.

SUMMERS: That's Kina Collins from the Illinois Council Against Handgun Violence. According to the Cook County medical examiner's office, there were 875 gun-related homicides there last year. Most of those killings happened in the city of Chicago.

COLLINS: Seventy-eight percent of those people were African Americans. I don't know any place in the country if we saw that many white folks dying by way of gun violence that we wouldn't call it a state of emergency.

SUMMERS: During the campaign, Biden described it as an epidemic. At a 2019 candidate forum organized by the gun groups Giffords and March For Our Lives, he got this question from activist Alicia Moten (ph).

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

ALICIA MOTEN: What is your plan to not only reduce gun violence in inner cities through economic justice such as reparations but to decriminalize the way...

(CHEERING)

MOTEN: ...But to decriminalize the way in which police and government view violence in Black and brown communities and removing stigmas and stereotypes around violence within communities of color?

SUMMERS: Biden said he wanted to dedicate $900 million to community based violence prevention programs in 40 cities with the highest rates of gun violence. He tried to relate to Moten in describing the racial disparities in who is killed.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

BIDEN: There is a mass shooting in my city of Wilmington, your city of Chicago, all the cities that have large brown and Black populations, every single day - every single day. What gets the headlines - and it should - are the mass shootings that are the ones that people see where there are two, five, 10, 20, 100 people shot.

SUMMERS: Now that Biden's in office, senior officials are taking the lead on the administration's outreach on gun violence prevention. Susan Rice, who heads up the Domestic Policy Council, and Cedric Richmond, who heads up the Office of Public Engagement, have been holding meetings with key stakeholders. After an initial meeting in February with gun control groups, including Everytown for Gun Safety, Moms Demand Action, Giffords and Brady, a number of leaders who were not included expressed their frustration with the White House.

EDDIE BOCANEGRA: And some of these advocates were amazing organizations. I don't discredit them. I think they do some great work. But the challenge for us was that they were all white. And they didn't bring a lived experience. They didn't represent sort of the urban communities, per se.

SUMMERS: That was Eddie Bocanegra from READI Chicago. He was a part of a group that came together during the Biden transition to focus on gun violence-related policies.

BOCANEGRA: We felt very disrespected by that. And it was a kind of a blow in terms of, like, well, who and what's informing the president's decisions in the next hundred days?

SUMMERS: Ultimately, the administration did hold additional meetings with groups focused on community gun violence prevention, as well as survivors of gun violence. Multiple participants described these as listening sessions and said that the early conversations have been encouraging. Several pointed to the leading roles of Rice and Richmond. Luis Hernandez is a co-founder of Youth Over Guns.

LUIS HERNANDEZ: The reality is that Susan Rice and Cedric Richmond are both Black people. They're folks who know all too well what it's - what the Black experience is in America. And so they bring that lens to the work.

SUMMERS: One big thing that all these different gun groups share is a sense of urgency and impatience. There's frustration that Biden has yet to issue one executive action to combat gun violence in this country or make good on the money he pledged to invest in community violence prevention efforts during the campaign. Hernandez says he hopes that whatever action the administration takes is proactive.

HERNANDEZ: I think we need to be preventative rather than reactive in our policy. And for too long, our policy has been reactive, only serving as a measure to react whenever gun violence occurs, react whenever another shooting happens, whether it be on our streets or in our schools.

KING: OK, Juana. He's making an interesting point about being reactive. But the fact of the matter is the White House now is reacting. What are they saying they are doing?

SUMMERS: Yeah. So President Biden was asked last week whether he had made a decision about executive actions on a host of gun-related matters. The president described this as "a matter of timing" - and I'm quoting him there - saying that presidents are successful because they know how to time policy rollouts and things like that, as well as how to prioritize different issues. And then he turned the conversation to the issue of infrastructure. And that pivot - it left many advocates really dumbfounded, frankly, after the urgency with which Biden spoke about gun violence when he was a candidate. And last week, White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki said that there would be more efforts coming by Biden and his administration to move on these sorts of issues. But she didn't provide any sort of timetable. Now, Noel, I did follow up at the White House directly, including a number of questions about why this is not more of a priority, as well as where they stand on that funding for community violence prevention efforts that the president promised as a candidate. And the White House did decline comment.

KING: NPR's Juana Summers. Thanks so much, Juana.

SUMMERS: You're welcome. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.