Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

David and Art - Confrontational Art

When art can make you feel crowded out, you're experiencing it's power to confront your assumptions.

Last week we talked about an American sculptor named Richard Serra who, over the course of his career, came to see his art-and often himself-described as "confrontational." He was famously gruff, yes, but what about his art led people to describe it that way?

Serra's works are, in the main, instantly recognizable, particularly his later pieces. His signature material for his sculptures was something called corten steel, which is a steel alloy designed to develop a rust-like surface pretty quickly as it ages. (Sometimes it's referred to as "weathered steel.") It looks like something from an age long passed. It's got a very distinctive appearance, especially when Serra creates big pieces with it.

In 1986, reviewing a show of Serra's at the Museum of Modern Art, critic Hilton Kramer said, of his pieces, that "their outsize forms tend either to impede or direct our movements in or around them," and so, "to take an interest in these works is, to some extent, to surrender to their scale, which is not so much a human scale as a scale designed to diminish our sense of autonomy and volition." If you're someone who's impressed with your scale and abilities and power, such an encounter is pretty confrontational. His works are quite obviously not going to cede the right of way.

Kramer added that "What is original in his work may not always be to our liking, perhaps- but it nonetheless leaves the art of sculpture significantly altered." Considering that sculpture has been around sort of a long time, that's a big deal.

In the 70s Serra took his impulses outside, enlarged them vastly, and began working with site-specific works that challenged the viewer, you could say, for control of a space. Some of his pieces like this stretched upward, others extended in the horizontal plane. Both sorts impinged on the viewer who approached them. He showed us the capabilities of what art can actually do-how it can make us feel. Most of us are familiar with works of art that can make us feel happy or melancholy or contemplative. Fewer of us have experienced art that makes us feel small and insignificant, art that gives us a window into how it feels to be manipulated and intimidated and powerless. Serra's art can do that. And that's a big deal because it expands what art can do for us.

David and Art - "I Love LA"
In the mid-twentieth century, Los Angeles joined New York as a center of contemporary art. How it happened is a good story.
David & Art - Cindy Walker and her House
David Smith delves into the fascinating story of an overlooked but influential songwriter, and the efforts to preserve her local historic home.
David and Art - Art in One Place
Standing in the very spots where history was made transforms our understanding and connection to the past.
David and Art - Frank Stella
Without even trying, painter Frank Stella took all of American art in a radically new direction.
David and Art - Vinnie Ream
The story of the Naval hero and the woman who created his monument is one that's not very well known in the nation's capital.
David and Art - Very Public Confrontations
Should public art actually confront the public? Says who?
David and Art - Richard Serra
Remembering a sculptor whose work showed how assertive art can be.
David and Art - "Quincy"
He started out as a trumpeter, and from there went on to shape pop music more than any other single person.
David and Art - “What is Art—and a Museum—For?”
What stories could art museums be telling, just from a row of paintings on the wall?
David and Art - “Harry Belafonte at the Lincoln Memorial”
From the steps of the Lincoln Memorial, a popular singer once explained what the arts bring to society.

David Smith, host of David and Art, is an American historian with broad interests in his field. He’s been at Baylor University since 2002 teaching classes in American history, military history, and cultural history. For eight years he wrote an arts and culture column for the Waco Tribune-Herald, and his writings on history, art, and culture have appeared in other newspapers from the Wall Street Journal to the Dallas Morning News.