David and Art - What's In A Name?

Here’s a question for you: Does knowing that a particular work of art was painted by a famous painter make you like it more? How much does the name on the canvas influence what you think of it? Or even how much you like it? Would you like “Girl with a Balance” less if it were suddenly discovered that it did not come from the hand of Vermeer but from a copycat?

One of the hottest topics in the art world is the challenge of accurate attribution. Establishing the validity of a work of art is regarded as a central responsibility of museums and galleries. If a piece is presented to the public--whether in an exhibit or in an auction--as being the work of a certain master the claim has to be verified. As anyone knows who even halfway keeps up with the sales at high-profile auction houses, an accurate assessment of a painting's source can be a matter of millions or tens of millions of dollars. A year or so ago, the FBI seized a handful of paintings from a blockbuster show at the Orlando Museum of Art. They were purported to be heretofore unknown works by artist Jean-Michel Basquiat who died in 1988 at age 27. There were clues that some of them might not be genuine. A Los Angeles art auctioneer finally admitted to forging them. Clearly, they weren’t worth what was initially thought. Basquiat is hot, and gallery owners far and wide probably breathed a sigh of relief that they didn’t get caught up in the whole thing.

But what if it's not an investment? What if you just love it? A few years ago, I bought a print by a remarkable New Mexico artist named Brian Coble, of whom relatively few people have ever heard. I figure that the chances of my liking it because “it’s a Coble” are pretty small. I like it because of what it is, because of the visual impact of the image itself, how it looks. Not because A) it’s done by a famous artist whose name, when dropped at a party, would elicit Oooo’s and Ahhh’s; nor B) because it will appreciate through the years more than will all those shares of Radio Shack stock.

 With art what matters most, what really counts in the end, is if you like it. If it brings you joy or comfort, if it makes you sad or brings you to the edge of inexplicable tears, if it awakens your sense of wonder, curiosity, or admiration, or even if it makes you uneasy, that’s what makes it art. Everything else is secondary. If you’re wondering if the work will be worth more next year than it is now, you’re not thinking of it as art.

RECENT EPISODES OF DAVID AND ART

David and Art - Guernica Part Two

Last week on David and Art, we looked at the origins of a well-known painting. Today, host David Smith picks up the story and traces where it went next.

David and Art - Guernica

On today’s David and Art, host David Smith looks at how one of the 20th century’s most well-known paintings came out of a moment of war—and why it still draws attention today.

David and Art - Remembering a Critic

On today’s David and Art, host David Smith looks back at the life and work of a longtime art critic whose writing helped bring clarity to the modern art world, and offered readers a closer look at the artists behind it.

David and Art - Art and National Identity, Part 2

Ideas about national identity don’t just show up in politics—they show up in art and architecture, too. Today on David and Art, host David Smith continues that conversation.

David and Art - "Art and National Identity"

David Smith gives some insight as to how nations use are and architecture to define who they are.

David and Art - "The Art of a Seapower"

Art doesn't just reflect history - it can shape how we see ourselves.

David and Art - “The Theater and the University”

College campuses are places for discovery, and not all of it happens in a classroom. Today on David and Art, host David Smith looks at the role theater can play in a university education.

David and Art - John Cale

Today on David and Art, host David Smith traces the unusual path of a musician whose work helped bridge classical experimentation and rock and roll.

David and Art - A Little Global Perspective

On today's David and Art, David Smith connects Art and History through paintings that reveal how Europe followed the American Civil War, in real time.

David and Art - Open Mic Night

On today’s David and Art, host David Smith takes us inside a jazz club in New York’s West Village for a look at what happens when musicians who’ve never met share a stage—and what that kind of collaboration can teach us.