Texas has been an incubator for Christian nationalist policies, with a Lieutenant Governor who believes the church-state wall should be torn down and champions legislation mandating the 10 Commandments be posted in public school classrooms.
But this month’s blue wave appears to have halted that movement, at least for now.
Last month, Texas Monthly‘s Robert Downen joined us for a deep dive into the infusion of Christian nationalism into our state and federal government. We caught up with Downen for his post-election assessment.
These interview highlights have been edited for length and clarity. To hear the full conversation, click the play button above.
Last time we spoke, you laid out all the ways in which Christian nationalism was really moving into the mainstream, led in great part by Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick. Before we get into how that movement’s been effectively kneecapped, remind our listeners what was taking shape in the U.S.
Specifically over the last few months, but really in the second Trump era, there has been a concerted push by Christian nationalists to codify their opposition to church-state separation into federal policy. We really saw that with this DOJ Religious Liberty Commission, led by Patrick, that was looking to reorient the entire apparatus of the federal government around this idea that church-state separation is a myth and that America was founded as a true Christian nation.
At the state level, we saw the State Board of Education making drastic revisions to K-12 curricula, so as to kind of recast America as a Christian nation. Patrick was gearing up to do all of that, to further those goals even more in the Texas Senate during the next Texas legislative session. You also had Mays Middleton, the Republican nominee for Attorney General, who had kind of built his brand on opposition to the idea that church-state separation is a myth. So, really at every level of policy in governments, there were Christian nationalists who were ascendant and then [Election Day] came.
What are your predictions for the future of the Christian nationalist movement?
We wrote a piece last week that pronounced the Christian nationalist agenda dead, and I want to be very clear — I saw some people saying Christian nationalism was never dead, and I agree with that 1,000%. For right now, their legislative agenda is dead, though.
This is a movement that has always, arguably, been at its most motivated and at its best and most creative when it is on its back foot, when it doesn’t have institutional power. So, I think that it would be very foolish to pronounce this movement dead entirely, even if they did see a generational setback. At the same time though, I think that one of the reasons they’ve been so aggressive with their policy agenda, especially in the Trump era, is that a lot of them saw Trump and they looked at the demographic trends; they looked at the broader rise of secularism in America, they looked at poll after poll that showed that even the tenets of their ideology are barely cracking 50% even in Oklahoma, the kind of buckle of the Bible belt. I mean, these are not popular policies, and so the approach that they’ve always taken is this additive strategy where they can use something like the Texas Legislature to slowly move the ball and to slowly normalize things over time in ways that don’t draw widespread opposition, but slowly, again, both make the legal and political basis for their next step in the policy.
I think that’s probably what they’re going to try to do in the future, but it’s going to be much more difficult now that they don’t have the Texas House, or the Texas Attorney General’s Office, but again, this movement is far from over.
We had 12 contests around the country, as you point out in your piece, where clergy appeared on the ballot. As someone put it here, ‘They were speaking about the Bible in a way that resonated with people outside of Christian national extremism.’
As with almost every American election, the core motivating factor is almost always going to be the economy, and I think it would be wrong to read this election as an explicit rebuke of the Christian nationalist movement. But at the same time, if you look at maybe not Christian nationalism itself, but the ways that Christian nationalists operated in policy — this very muscular, intense, kind of like take-no-prisoner’s hardline view of politics — that was really endemic to so many figures who had wrapped themselves in this kind of cultural or existentialist view of the politics that is central to the Christian nationalist project. I think that this was, in many ways, a rebuking of them.
I remember more than a year ago talking to people and I was really of the mind that I think someone like James Talarico was articulating a version of Christianity that a lot of people, even if they are not religious themselves, were open to because I think a lot of people are just tired. I think people are struggling economically. They’re tired of the culture war, and I think that kind of articulation of faith really resonates.
Now, I do think though that there are spots in Texas where you can make a better case that this was an explicit rejection of Christian nationalism. The core place for that is at the State Board of Education and everything that’s been happening in schools. I mean, this was a pretty overtly Christian nationalist project that was going on there. The people who pushed that project … did not try to hide what they we’re doing. Now, the Republicans have lost their majority on the State Board of Education. You have a Governor, a Lieutenant Governor, et cetera, who all ran on public education, ran on getting rid of vouchers. It wouldn’t surprise me if there is a kind of big, omnibus type bill that’s [filed during the] legislative session that undoes all sorts of stuff, from taking the 10 Commandments out of classrooms to getting rid of this Bluebonnet [Learning cirriculum].
I don’t know if the legislature could do that, but I think that there’s a lot of creative ways that they could push back against this agenda, and I do think that they have a real mandate from voters.
Miranda Suarez and Ron Corning are the hosts of KERA’s NTX Now. Got a tip? Email Miranda at msuarez@kera.org or Ron at rcorning@kera.org.
KERA News is made possible through the generosity of our members. If you find this reporting valuable, consider making a tax-deductible gift today. Thank you.
Copyright 2026 KERA News