The new PBS documentary series “Crime and Punishment in America” explores a central question: How did we arrive at a criminal justice system that remains one of the most debated institutions in the country?
The four-part, eight-hour series airing this week on KERA-TV traces the history of policing, prisons and punishment from colonial America to the present, exploring the tensions between justice and mercy — and accountability and redemption.
Ron Corning recently hosted a roundtable discussion about the evolution of America’s criminal justice system tied to the series. The panelists were director Lynn Novick; Law professor Pamela Metzger, executive director of SMU’s Deason Criminal Justice Reform Center; and Angelica Zaragoza, a prison reform advocate whose story of her time in prison is featured in the film.
These interview highlights have been edited for length and clarity. To hear the full conversation, click the play button above.
How much knowledge of our system of crime and punishment in America did you know?
Novick: You know, I’ve been making documentaries about different aspects of American history and culture for more than 30 years. And I’ve gone over our story in many different ways. And yet, I’d never paid much attention to the system of justice that we have, even though it is so central to our society and how we operate. And so when we embarked on this project, I knew a little bit. I knew that America was the world’s leading incarcerator. And I knew that we had a reputation for a harsh system. But most of what we learned along the way of making this film was new to me.
When someone says to me, “what is institutional racism?” I believe you could point them to Episode 1 of “Crime and Punishment” to understand that our system of incarceration is really institutional racism.
Novick: Well, you can’t talk about American history without really taking a deep look at the question of race, the legacy of slavery and the Declaration of Independence — that all men are created equal, endowed with certain inalienable rights, life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. More than anything else, this is what makes us American — that we adhere to this creed. And at the same time, we have not lived up to that. And the question of race and the legacy of slavery is at the center of that. It’s not the only reason, but it’s a big part of that story. And when you look at the way that we do justice, it’s sort of an amplification of that critical problem that we faced.
Pamela, the 13th Amendment also has that carve out that says slavery is abolished with the exception of as a form of punishment for crimes. And as is so well outlined in this documentary series, that is the means by which slaves were then incarcerated and leased out for labor. That has to inform your students as they learn about this system via the Constitution.
Metzger: Yeah, that’s right. There’s no way to think about the American criminal legal system without understanding it as a part of this country’s original sin. It just is. Policing was formed by slavery, conflict lend-lease, prison labor, the notion of a disenfranchisement — that we’ve empowered one group of people, police, law enforcement, judges — to make decisions about what other group of people get to vote, notwithstanding what’s in our constitution. Which other group of people get to serve as citizens on juries? And we’ve created a system, which is a legacy of slavery, in which the least empowered people — that minority — have no voice at all in how the majority continues to treat them.
Angelica, you know this system from the inside out, from your own experience. What was it like for you seeking representation when you were facing the charges that you were facing?
Zaragoza: Well, I’ve got to say, my last charge was a burglary of a habitation. And when I got arrested on that charge … nobody could tell me why I was arrested, other than burglary of a habitation. It was three months before I went to jail that I found out it was because I pawned a nail gun six months before that was a part of a burglary that I got from someone that I had no ties to. So, it wasn’t justified. I wasn’t provided a lawyer. I wasn’t told what was going on or what was gonna happen. I went in blind. And that was the God’s honest truth. I went in blind.
Were some of your crimes a matter of survival?
Zaragoza: All of them were a matter of survival at the point that I started committing crimes. It was feeding that next habit. It was trying to put food on the table of my kids and not able to get a job, because I had been incarcerated before. There was X’s on my back so where I couldn’t get a a job at some point.
Your story, Angelica, is one of healing and redemption and finding your way back. And in that, I think there might be some answers to how the system could be fixed. And I want to know, Pam, what’s happening here at the [SMU] law school that you think is a bright spot for the future as we look forward.
Metzger: So, what we do at the Deason Center is we focus on what happens on Day 1. It’s our belief that Day 1 is the best time to change lives. It’s the best time to downsize the system.
We believe deeply that when you’re arrested, what separates that arrest from a kidnapping is the fact that you’re going to see a lawyer. Otherwise, it’s just someone picking you up. If you’ve been arrested and your kids on the school bus, what separates your child from foster care and you from the panic of not knowing who’s gonna meet your child is having a lawyer advocating for them zealously from the beginning of the case to the end.
And if you do that, the end of the the case comes sooner, the results are better, people stay with their families, they get treatment rather than punishment, and the system gets smaller. Now, that can’t fix all of it. But that’s what we can do in our corner of the world.
Miranda Suarez and Ron Corning are the hosts of KERA’s NTX Now. Got a tip? Email Miranda at msuarez@kera.org or Ron at rcorning@kera.org.
KERA News is made possible through the generosity of our members. If you find this reporting valuable, consider making a tax-deductible gift today. Thank you.
Copyright 2026 KERA News