David and Art - Rock Me, Amadeus.

The BBC calls it the most misunderstood Oscar winner ever. Amadeus, the dramatic, semi-biographical movie about the composer Mozart came out in 1984—40 years ago. It won 8 Academy Awards including Best Picture, Best Actor, Best Director, Best Screenplay, Best Art Direction, Best Costumes, Best Sound, and Best Makeup. It’s one of my favorite movies—if not my very favorite.

 It was based on a 1979 play by Peter Shaffer with the same title. Shaffer, in turn, based his work on another play called Mozart and Salieri by Russian playwright Alexander Pushkin written in 1830—just five years after Salieri himself died. 67 years after Pushkin’s play, Russian composer Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov made it into an opera. So, it’s a story that’s had a lot of attention through the centuries.

And throughout those years, especially in the wake of the movie’s success, any number of writers have cataloged its historical inaccuracies.

There’s a scene in the movie where Salieri pledges his chastity to God if God will make him a great composer. People have pointed out that Salieri was certainly not chaste—he was married and had eight children. Mozart wasn’t a necessarily heavy drinker, but the movie shows him to be. While it’s accurate, as the movie shows, that Mozart did receive an anonymous commission to compose a funeral mass, it most definitely wasn’t some sort of complicated set-up by Salieri. (An Austrian nobleman named Franz von Walsegg was the one who commissioned it if you’re curious.)

The movie shows Salieri stewing with rage at Mozart’s successes, but he was a supporter of his fellow composer, cheered his works, and the two composed at least one work together. It’s true that for a while Mozart and his father blamed the Italian composers in Emperor Joseph’s court for closing off opportunities for German composers, but Italian opera was all the rage—it wasn’t personal.

We talked last week about J.M.W. Turner’s 1822 painting of the battle of Trafalgar and how much criticism it came in for because it wasn’t accurate in every aspect. The criticism didn’t matter to Turner at all. Should it matter to us? Does it change your opinion of anything to know that Emmanuel Leutze’s famous painting of Washington crossing the Delaware River is wildly inaccurate? Do you care that Longfellow’s poem about “The Midnight Ride of Paul Revere” is a farrago of inaccuracies? Where do you draw the line?

RECENT EPISODES OF DAVID AND ART

David and Art - Remembering a Critic

On today’s David and Art, host David Smith looks back at the life and work of a longtime art critic whose writing helped bring clarity to the modern art world, and offered readers a closer look at the artists behind it.

David and Art - Art and National Identity, Part 2

Ideas about national identity don’t just show up in politics—they show up in art and architecture, too. Today on David and Art, host David Smith continues that conversation.

David and Art - "Art and National Identity"

David Smith gives some insight as to how nations use are and architecture to define who they are.

David and Art - "The Art of a Seapower"

Art doesn't just reflect history - it can shape how we see ourselves.

David and Art - “The Theater and the University”

College campuses are places for discovery, and not all of it happens in a classroom. Today on David and Art, host David Smith looks at the role theater can play in a university education.

David and Art - John Cale

Today on David and Art, host David Smith traces the unusual path of a musician whose work helped bridge classical experimentation and rock and roll.

David and Art - A Little Global Perspective

On today's David and Art, David Smith connects Art and History through paintings that reveal how Europe followed the American Civil War, in real time.

David and Art - Open Mic Night

On today’s David and Art, host David Smith takes us inside a jazz club in New York’s West Village for a look at what happens when musicians who’ve never met share a stage—and what that kind of collaboration can teach us.

David and Art - The Artists and the President

Continuing his exploration of the problematic background behind Lynden B. Johnson's White House Arts festival, here's David Smith with this weeks installment of David and Art.

David and Art - When the Art World Came to washington

Despite his advocacy for the arts, Lyndon B. Johnson's tenure in the White House also brought political friction to the creative consciousness of 1960's America. With this week's edition of David and Art, here's David Smith.