Tiny bits of twisted plant fibers found on an ancient stone tool suggest that Neanderthals were able to make and use sophisticated cords like string and rope.
Cords made from twisted fibers are so ubiquitous today that it's easy to take them for granted. But they're a key survival technology that can be used to make everything from clothes to bags to shelters.
This prehistoric piece of string, described in the journal Scientific Reports, was preserved on a flint tool that dates back to around 41,000 to 52,000 years ago. It came from a cave-like rock shelter in southern France that was once inhabited by Neanderthals.
The discovery adds to growing evidence that our closest extinct human relative wasn't as dumb as scientists had long assumed.
"They are this sort of ultimate 'other,' this creature that is very similar to us yet somehow is supposed to be too stupid to live," said Bruce Hardy, a paleoanthropologist at Kenyon College in Ohio. He points out that Neanderthals were smart enough to have persisted for hundreds of thousands of years before eventually disappearing around 40,000 years ago.
But understanding their lives has been hard because archaeologists typically only find human remains, animal bones and stone tools. "Almost everything that we want to see is gone," Hardy said. "And so we have to try to find ways to get as much as we can out of the material that we do have."
On the surfaces of stone tools, he explains, it's sometimes possible to find residues of materials that would otherwise decay. How this preservation happens isn't well understood. But if a tool is put on top of another material, for example, it might create a kind of capsule or micro-environment that can keep things stable.
"Starch grains, bits and pieces of plants, hair, feathers — things like this can all survive," Hardy said.
He was examining one stone tool when he saw some flecks of white that he then peered at through a microscope. "It was a mass of twisted fibers," he said. "It was clear that we had something, as soon as I saw it."
Additional work with a more powerful microscope revealed what looks like a classic structure used to make string. "What we have found is a small fragment of a three-ply cord," said Hardy, adding that it's made from fibers that come from the inner bark of some kind of evergreen tree.
"There are three bundles of fibers that are twisted counterclockwise, and then those bundles, once they are twisted, are twisted back the other way, clockwise, around each other to form a cord or string," he added.
Previously, the oldest known fragment of cord dated back to around 19,000 years ago, from a site in Israel. Scientists had also found impressions left in clay by something that looked like woven fibers, from 27,000 years ago.
Marie-Hélène Moncel of the National Museum of Natural History in Paris, who is part of the research team that worked on this new discovery, said it's impossible that the twisted structure found on the tool just appeared spontaneously from nature — it had to be intentionally constructed.
"It was amazing," she said.
And given where the artifact was found, and the other bones and tools found at the site, she said, "It is clear that this is related to Neanderthals," and not the anatomically modern humans that began showing up in Europe around 40,000 years ago.
John Shea, a paleoanthropologist at Stony Brook University in New York, isn't so sure.
"The idea that this cordage is necessarily made by Neanderthals, that is open to question," he said, even if Neanderthal remains were found right nearby. "You still have to keep an open mind. That just means that Neanderthals were present. It doesn't rule out the possibility that humans were wandering around this same part of the world at the same time."
Still, he added, "We've long suspected that earlier humans and Neanderthals had some kind of cordage, some means by which to attach one thing to another. This is, as far as I know, some of the first definitive proof."
Cordage was probably in use as far back as half-a-million years ago, Shea said. He noted that some extremely old stone tools appear to have been made to fit handles, and such tools will work loose from a handle pretty swiftly without glue and cordage to keep it bound tight.
It's pretty easy to use almost any weed to make cordage, Shea said: "You can make simple cordage in minutes."
Making high-quality string and rope, however, takes some know-how. And he said there's no reason to think that Neanderthals wouldn't be capable of that.
"There's not one shred, and I mean not even the slightest trace of evidence," he said, "that Neanderthals were deficient in terms of their intelligence compared to humans."
ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:
Scientists have found something surprising on a prehistoric stone tool. It is a tiny piece of string. And as NPR's Nell Greenfieldboyce reports, it's an intriguing clue about the lives of our closest extinct human relative, the Neanderthal.
NELL GREENFIELDBOYCE, BYLINE: For a long time, scientists assumed that Neanderthals were primitive dolts.
BRUCE HARDY: They are this creature that is very similar to us, yet somehow is supposed to be too stupid to live.
GREENFIELDBOYCE: Bruce Hardy doesn't buy that vision of Neanderthals. He's a paleo-anthropologist at Kenyon College in Ohio. He points out that Neanderthals were smart enough to have persisted for hundreds of thousands of years. All that's left for archaeologists to find now, though, is basically just bones and stone tools.
HARDY: Most everything that we want to see is gone.
GREENFIELDBOYCE: However, sometimes, microscopic residues of materials can persist on the surface of stone tools. Hardy was recently using a microscope to examine the surface of one flint tool. It came from a cave-like rock shelter in southern France that was once inhabited by Neanderthals. And on this particular tool, he spotted something amazing.
HARDY: It was a mass of twisted fibers. It took us a while to kind of understand the technology that was going on. But it was clear that we had something as soon as I saw it.
GREENFIELDBOYCE: What they had was string, a cord made by skillfully twisting together fibers from the inner bark of some kind of evergreen tree.
HARDY: They're three bundles of fibers that are twisted counterclockwise. And then those bundles, once they're twisted, are twisted back the other way, clockwise, around each other to form a cord or string.
GREENFIELDBOYCE: The find is described in the journal Scientific Reports. This sophisticated string dates back to around 40,000 to 50,000 years ago. It shows that Neanderthals may have mastered a key technology that's ubiquitous today. Cords and ropes let people do everything from making clothes to sailing the high seas. John Shea is a paleo-anthropologist at Stony Brook University in New York.
JOHN SHEA: We've long suspected that earlier humans and Neanderthals had some kind of cordage, some means by which to attach one thing to another. This is, as far as I know, some of the first definitive proof.
GREENFIELDBOYCE: He says it's possible that modern humans were wandering around that part of the world and made this string. But he thinks Neanderthals were plenty smart enough to figure out how to tie things together.
Nell Greenfieldboyce, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.