© 2025 KWBU
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

David and Art - Debussy, the Second Movement.

Further examining the evocative work of Claude Debussy.

A couple of weeks ago we jumped headlong into a piece of music we’ve never talked about before—really, that I’d never listened to prior to about a month ago: Claude Debussy’s String Quartet in G# minor. It’s the only string quartet Debussy ever wrote, and it debuted in Paris at the end of December, 1893.

 In his book Modernism, historian Peter Gay calls Debussy one of the pacesetters of Modernism and portrays him even at a young age as someone unwilling to adjust his compositional inclinations to conform with what was expected. He writes that as a boy taking lessons, Debussy “irritated his piano teacher by devising sacrilegious little Preludes,” and that he would take orders “only from himself.” Later in life about his own music Debussy said, “I am too fond of my freedom, and my own ideas”

 One conservative critic at the time called his compositions “bizarre, incomprehensible, and impossible to execute.” Well, the first two comments may, from some perspectives, be accurate; the third is most certainly not. Just listen to any recording.

 The second movement of the quartet is more sedate than the first and it starts with some of the players playing pizzicato for the first time—that is, plucking the strings with their fingertips instead of using the bow. The overall impression is one of curious cats walking around something they can’t figure out and didn’t see come in. “Catlike” isn’t a bad description of the second movement in fact. When the viola and cello take the lead, the violins stand back and watch, and then vice versa. There’s more stillness in between the phrases in this movement than in the first. Periodic ascending phrases sort of separate the movement into manageable parts.

 Then, pizzicato returns as if they’re again walking around and looking at what they’ve been pondering. Little two measure phrases are passed back and forth. Then the second movement flows right into the third without a pause, and this one is quieter still. There are sections in which only one instrument seems to have the floor, speaking for them all perhaps. Gradually you hear extended musings from the lower end of the scale and the others creep in, making it seem like they’ve been gone a while.

 “There’s nothing descriptive about the music,” of Modernism, write music historians Howard McKinney and W.R. Anderson. “It simply strives to evoke in the listener’s mind something of the feeling which its creator experienced in writing it.” Such is one of the main goals of Modernism and Debussy’s music does it perfectly. It’s worth your attention.

RECENT EPISODES OF DAVID AND ART
David and Art - Matthias the Painter
Sometimes art inspires more art. Composer Paul Hindemith found that spark in the paintings of Matthias Grünewald, creating Mathis der Maler—a piece that became both a symphony and an opera. It’s music that wrestles with creativity, politics, and the fight for artistic freedom in the shadow of Nazi Germany.
David and Art - The Art of War
This week on David and Art, David Smith looks at how artists and writers have portrayed war—not just the battles, but the people living through them.
David and Art - More Scarcity
This week on David and Art, David Smith looks at how artists use their work to reveal scarcity in dignity, opportunity, and connection.
David and Art - Not from Abundance
Most classic art celebrates abundance. This week, David explores work born of something else.
David and Art - A Man Ray Kind of Sky
On this weeks edition of David and Art, host David Smith muses on a particular example of human inspiration behind surralist art.
David and Art - Others Beside Susan
This week on David and Art, we meet the remarkable women artists who painted, sculpted, and persevered through the progressive era. Here's your host David Smith.
David and Art - Starting with Susan Watkins
This week on David and Art: A Memphis exhibit opens the door some remarkable women artists history almost forgot.
David and Art - Books
With intrigue, curiosity, and a few good resources, anyone can learn about art and art history. With plenty of encouragement and a number of valuable recommendations, here’s David Smith with this week’s edition of David and Art.
David and Art - The Great American Songbook
What do U2, Ella Fitzgerald, and Roy Rogers have in common? On this weeks edition of David and art, host David Smith fills you in.
David and Art - Hamilton as History
You're listening to 103.3 Waco Public Radio. This week on David and Art: A hit musical, a founding father, and a few questions about how we see history. Here's your host - David Smith

David Smith, host of David and Art, is an American historian with broad interests in his field. He’s been at Baylor University since 2002 teaching classes in American history, military history, and cultural history. For eight years he wrote an arts and culture column for the Waco Tribune-Herald, and his writings on history, art, and culture have appeared in other newspapers from the Wall Street Journal to the Dallas Morning News.