© 2025 KWBU
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Likely Stories - The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year by Ally Carter

It’s not Christmastime anymore, but that's never stopped me from enjoying any story set during the most wonderful time of the year. This one is heavy on mystery, lightly romantic, deeply nostalgic, fully entrenched in the setting.

Hello, and welcome to Likely Stories. I’m Paige Connell, and I teach English at Midway High School.

The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year by Ally Carter has become a book I recommend to everyone, and I can't sing its praises enough.

Maggie is the top crime fiction writer at her publishing house, but her personal life is in turmoil, and along comes fellow author Ethan to seemingly rub salt in her wounds. She’s the “Queen of the Cozy Mystery”, and he’s “Mr. Big Time Thriller Guy” in a leather jacket. The two have a history-separately and together-so when they are tapped by their editors to spend Christmas with Eleanor Ashley, the grande dame of fiction herself, they begrudgingly go together.

Eleanor's infamous mansion is set to host an eclectic group of holiday travelers-a cousin, a lawyer, a doctor, a duke & duchess, a butler, a nanny, and more (but no partridge in a pear tree). All hell breaks loose when Eleanor disappears from a locked room in her mansion-and then come gunshots, poisoned tea trays, fires, and secret passages. Maggie knows she can use her sleuthing skills from her books to figure out what happened to Eleanor (is she dead? Hiding? Testing them? Scamming everyone?), but she also will have to depend on Ethan, the only person she seems able to trust in a blizzard-locked labyrinth.

If he'll stop calling her Marcie and start looking at her with those gorgeous blue eyes, can Maggie possibly feel something other than contempt for Ethan? Perhaps she can accomplish both objectives–finding Ms. Ashley and finding her heart’s desire.

I just loved everything about The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year by Ally Carter. Maggie and Ethan both have narrating voices, and their enemies-to-lovers arc is snappy and believable. The mystery of Eleanor harkens back to Agatha Christie and Murder on the Orient Express with such an eclectic cast of characters, many of whom could be hiding secrets. I liked the layered way we revealed our characters’ back stories and the Poirot-esque exposition at the end (because if you know, you know) as everything wraps up when Maggie finally finds her confident voice. If you liked Knives Out or the classic Clue movie, you won’t want to miss this one, no matter what time of year you read it.

RECENT EPISODES OF LIKELY STORIES
Likely Stories - The Will of the Many by James Islington
The Will of the Many by James Islington...I don't know why more people aren't talking about this book, but that's exactly what I want to do today. Hello, and welcome to Likely Stories. I’m Paige Connell, and I teachEnglish at Midway High School.
Likely Stories - A Heavy Metal History Lesson by Josh Putnam
In his new book A Heavy Metal History Lesson, author Josh Putnam explores the historical backgrounds of 10 heavy metal songs.
Likely Stories - We Keep the Dead Close by Becky Cooper
In her first Likely Stories review, Kelly Craine explores We Keep the Dead Close by Becky Cooper—a gripping investigation into a decades-old Harvard murder. More than a true crime story, it’s a powerful meditation on memory, misogyny, and the life of Jane Britton. A compelling debut from a new voice on Likely Stories.
Likely Stories - The Gulf: The Making of an American Sea by Jack Davis
This is the Reverend Dr. Andrew Armond, associate rector of Saint Albans Episcopal Church here in Waco. Welcome to this week's edition of Likely Stories.
Likely Stories - When the Moon Hits Your Eye by John Scalzi
If you have ever wondered what it would be like if Star Trek The Next Generation and Monty Python had a baby, I expect that reading a John Scalzi novel is as close as you can get to experiencing it. I’m Gia Chevis with this week’s installment of Likely Stories.
Likely Stories - I See You've Called In Dead by John Kenney
Hello. My name is Douglas Henry, Dean of the Honors College at Baylor University, with this week’s edition of Likely Stories.
Likely Stories - The Saturday Night Ghost Club by Craig Davidson
The summer you turn 12 is the most magical and glorious of them all. Times stretches out before you, freedom is riding your bike all over the neighborhood, and every day is wonderful, especially if you spend it with your eccentric uncle going to all the best haunted spots in town.Welcome to Likely Stories, I’m Diane Kemper.
Likely Stories - Winters in the World: A Journey Through the Anglo-Saxon Year by Eleanor Parker
This is the Reverend Dr. Andrew Armond, associate rector of Saint Albans Episcopal Church here in Waco. Welcome to this week's edition of Likely Stories.
Likely Stories - My Favorite Thing is Monsters by Emil Ferris
Part murder mystery, part coming-of-age tale, My Favorite Thing is Monsters blends pulp horror, art history, and raw emotion into a stunning graphic novel experience. Told through a young girl's illustrated diary, Emil Ferris's masterpiece is unforgettable in both story and style.
Likely Stories - Roman Stories by Jhumpa Lahiri
Hello, I'm Rebecca Flavin, director of engaged learning curriculum and senior lecturer of political science at Baylor University. My friends will all attest. Two of my favorite things are reading and traveling. And when I can combine the two by reading books about places I travel, I am in heaven.

Paige Connell has been a Wacoan since 2002 when she attended Baylor University, fell in love with the city, and never left. She works at Midway High School and has been teaching English since 2009. Paige’s passion is reading: she regularly reads 120 books or more each year and loves to share her thoughts on Goodreads and social media. Additionally, Paige co-authored the children’s book Goodnight Waco on behalf of the Junior League of Waco in 2021. When she’s not reading or listening to a book, you can find her nursing a mug of tea, analyzing Taylor Swift lyrics for figurative language elements, or spending time with her family—her husband Chance, her daughter Cara, and her Corgi mutt Remy.