© 2026 KWBU
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Likely Stories - The Treasure Hunters Club by Tom Ryan

Welcome back to Likely Stories. I’m Paige Connell, and I teach English at Midway High School.

Billed as “Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone” meets “The Goonies”, I can confirm that this fun, winding story of buried treasure and buried secrets gives off strong vibes of that great book and the classic movie.

The Treasure Hunter’s Club by Tom Ryan is told through 3 very different character perspectives and points of view, and my only light complaint is that I had a hard time keeping the MANY characters and their offspring straight. But it was a layered read with lots of surprises along the way.

Years ago, a group of 5 boys playing in the woods discovered what they believed to be pirate treasure off the coast of their homes in beautiful Maple Bay, Nova Scotia.

Through a series of dramatic events (including subterfuge, manipulation, and death), the treasure was lost to the ages. Years later, Peter Barnett is 40, in a dead-end job and sort of a loser, until he receives a mysterious letter from his long-lost grandmother, letting him know that he has a home to inherit on Maple Bay.

Cass Jones is a writer who receives an offer for a year-long house sitting job on Maple Bay and decides to make the story of hidden treasure and intrigue the focus of her new book.

Danielle Feltzen, aged 14, is reeling from the loss of her grandfather. She is intrepid and dogged, and once she discovers that he left her clues about the treasure, she makes it her mission to honor his legacy and find it.

All three of these people are on a collision course with each other (though they don’t yet know it) and are carrying
many deep secrets from the past. Because when a life-changing amount of money is involved, or when life-changing secrets are threatened to be revealed, it doesn’t bring out people’s best sides.

I enjoyed all the storylines in this book, especially once they coalesced together. The original 5 boys grew up to have children and grandchildren who are present-day characters in the book, and sometimes those were a bit hard to keep straight—who belonged to whom and who was double-crossed by whom, etc. Still, it was intriguing and with enough surprises to keep me guessing until the end.

The Treasure Hunter’s Club is solid recommendation for anyone who loves a hunt.

PREVIOUS EPISODES OF LIKELY STORIES
Likely Stories - Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke
Haven’t we all thought at one point how nice it would be to get away from the hustle and bustle of workaday life and return to living in simpler times? To disconnect, to live off the land, to embrace true family values? It sounds so refreshing in theory, but I’m not sure I could hack it in reality.
Likely Stories - Bone Valley by Gilbert King
Sometimes the most meaningful gifts come with a story inside them. Bone Valley tells the haunting case of a young man convicted of murder—and the decades-long search for the truth that followed. It’s a gripping look at justice gone wrong, and what it takes to make it right. Trust me—you won’t see the final turn coming.
Likely Stories - The 10 by E. A. Hanks
Gia Chevis reviews The 10 by E.A. Hanks—a reflective road trip memoir about memory, identity, and finding meaning in small moments along the way.
Likely Stories - Theo of Golden by Allen Levi
A charming but mysterious stranger arrives in a college town. He skirts questions about himself and his past, but soon becomes a vital part of the community through his kindness, his generosity, and his willingness to be friends with anyone.Welcome to “Likely Stories.”I’m Diane Kemper.
Likely Stories - The Compound by Aisling Rawle
Love Island meets Lord of the Flies meets Survivor meets Big Brother is a heavy mantle for a book to carry, but it’s an accurate description of what you’ll think of when you read The Compound by Aisling Rawle.
Teaching Under the Influence by Sandra Walters
"Every Kid Deserves a Champion" is a famous quote by educator powerhouse Rita Pearson. For years, teachers have been considered champions for students regardless of their economic background, academic growth, race, or behavior. History.
Likely Stories - Katabasis by R.F. Kuang
Hello. My name is Douglas Henry, Dean of the Honors College at Baylor University, with this week’s edition of Likely Stories. Fantasy writer R.F. Kuang published her sixth novel last year. It’s called Katabasis, an odd but fitting Greek word for her story of academic misadventure.
Likely Stories - A Spot of Bother by Mark Haddon
Have you ever felt overwhelmed, and maybe just a bit freaked out, by the absurd enormity of inhabiting a fragile body in a rapidly-changing and dangerous world? George Hall has, a little too often. I’m Gia Chevis, and for this week’s installment of Likely Stories on KWBU, I’m recommending A Spot of Bother by Mark Haddon, author of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time.
Likely Stories - A Marriage at Sea by Sophie Elmhirst
A married couple’s long awaited adventure at sea becomes a disaster and a nearly four month long deperation to stay alive.
Likely Stories - The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern
I don't know if there is a more perfect book. I've read The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern five times (unheard of for someone like me who does not ever reread books), and each time I find myself utterly captivated by this beautiful, mystical story of love, magic, sweeping talents and mystery, and the ties that bind us to each other.

Paige Connell has been a Wacoan since 2002 when she attended Baylor University, fell in love with the city, and never left. She works at Midway High School and has been teaching English since 2009. Paige’s passion is reading: she regularly reads 120 books or more each year and loves to share her thoughts on Goodreads and social media. Additionally, Paige co-authored the children’s book Goodnight Waco on behalf of the Junior League of Waco in 2021. When she’s not reading or listening to a book, you can find her nursing a mug of tea, analyzing Taylor Swift lyrics for figurative language elements, or spending time with her family—her husband Chance, her daughter Cara, and her Corgi mutt Remy.